Hormone Therapy Litigation Verdicts and Settlements

Date

Venue

Plaintiff

Defendant(s)

Verdict

02/14/2010

PA

Foust

(deceased)

Wyeth

Defense verdict on case

specific causation

02/13/2010

PA

Singleton

Wyeth

Plaintiff verdict: $3.25 million and

$200,000 to husband

Punitive: $6 million

Post trial motions unsolved

11/12/2009

PA

Kendall

Wyeth and Pfizer

Plaintiff verdict: $ 6.3 million

Punitive: $ 28 million

10/11/2009

PA

Barton

Wyeth

Plaintiff verdict: $3.74 million

Punitive: $ 75 million

(Punitive verdict reduced to $5.6 million)

02/10/2008

AR

Scroggin

Wyeth and Pfizer

Plaintiff verdict:

$2.75 million

Paid by Wyeth after it lost the appeal.

Punitive: $27.1 million

U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8^th Circuit affirmed

compensatory award and ordered a new trial on punitives

against Wyeth, finding sufficient evidence

to sustain a punitive award.

09/09/2007

NV

Scofield

Wyeth

Verdict reduced by judge to:

$7.2 million

Punitives reduced by judge to:

$12 million

Defendant is appealing.

09/08/2007

NV

Forrester

Wyeth

Verdict reduced by judge to:

$7.9 million

Punitives reduced by judge to:

$13 million

09/07/2007

NV

Rowatt

Wyeth

Verdict reduced by judge to:

$7.5 million

Punitives reduced by judge to:

$10 million

Defendant is appealing

04/06/2007

PA

Simon

Wyeth and Pfizer

Verdict against Pfizer only:

$1.5 million

JNOV granted - on appeal to Penn intermediate
appellate court, verdict reinstated.

01/05/2007

AR

Rush

Wyeth

Defense verdict

01/04/2007

PA

Nelson II

Wyeth

Plaintiff verdict:

$3 million

JNOV granted - on appeal

01/03/2007

PA

Daniel

Wyeth

Plaintiff verdict:

$1.5 million

Punitives awarded (amount sealed at Wyeth's request).
Judgment vacated - new trial ordered now on appeal.

09/02/2006

PA

Nelson

Wyeth

Plaintiff verdict:

$1.5 million

Trial was bifurcated and mistrial declared before punitives

submitted. Mistrial declared after compensatory verdict

due to jury misconduct.

09/01/2006

AR

Reeves

Wyeth

Defense verdict